• 2 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 25th, 2026

help-circle




  • I loved watching the hobbit in the cinema, but i was a kid and I don’t think I will ever sit down to watch it all again.

    The first one felt okay to have as one long film, i.e natural, but it’s weird that it would end with the eagle rescue after Goblin town.

    If i think about it off the top of my head, some scenes they stretched out in film 1 (“An Unexpected Journey”) were:

    • The “prelude” scenes of E r e b o r, which were very beautiful and cinematic, but most movies would convey in one or two scenes.
    • confrontations such as with the trolls and the goblins
    • CGI sequences like Radagast leading the wargs away from the dwarves

    I’ve not thought about it before but it really is a shame because as soon as a shorter version comes along, people will prioritise that film instead.







  • It strikes me as very sciencey.

    • The space travel, for instance, is “how could space travel actually work?” And even when they have a satisfying explanation for planet to planet travel, they need one for longer distances, so they introduce those wormhole gates? I haven’t read very far into it
    • it tries to make space colonisation as realistic as possible, including the body horror
    However it then surprises the reader by introducing

    the alien plague

    And therein lies the balance. Real science for where we know (or think we know) the boundaries of science, and completely theoretical fantasy for things we don’t know about (the existence of alien life and what shape it might take)