I’m starting to get annoyed with Lemmy. None of the posts I delete seem to disappear from the internet. My profile still shows up in other communities, and everything I delete—posts and comments—still seems visible to people. It’s really annoying. Sometimes I want something to disappear for good, but it’s still there for people to read or see. Am I the only one who thought I’d actually deleted it? -_-


Since everyone else has already answered your main question, it’s also worth pointing out that all of your upvotes and downvotes are mostly public due to the nature of the Fediverse and needing to publish that info.
There are ways to mitigate that, such as using PieFed and setting your votes to only count locally, or to only federate to “trusted” instances. Otherwise, another way to handle it is to use a “voting only” account and don’t make any comments with it.
Not sure if you know the answer to this, but since your comment reminded me of it I’m going to ask you, random Lemmy stranger.
Sometimes while scrolling through Lemmy on my phone I will accidentally click downvote on a post or comment. I usually immediately notice and clear my downvote out.
Would that downvote stay in my public voting history and could it populate across instances?
I do this a lot 😅. My experience has been that it gets changed to an upvote in almost all cases, but occasionally it stays as a downvote. It seems it doesn’t keep both, if that’s your question.
But if someone wanted to track the history they could absolutely do that by creating custom code on their instance.
TL/DR: Archival instances might, but most (even Lemvotes) won’t hold onto that.
Anything you post or do is shared out to a much wider audience. You might be using a Lemmy account, but interactions are shared with Twitter-like instances (Mastodon) as much as they are shared with other Reddit-like (Threadiverse) instances such as PieFed or Mbin, as well as other kinds of instances that interact with the Fediverse.
Even Meta has a presence here on the Fediverse with Threads. You just don’t see a lot of Threads users toggling their account over to interact with the rest of the Fediverse, but there are a few who do. Granted, upvotes and downvotes aren’t displayed for most Twitter-like instances. So, I would say it’s unlikely that they are recording that.
If you accidentally downvote a post or a comment that information will be sent out to every other instance which is connected (federated) with yours. As I mentioned before, you could set up an account to limit how votes are shared which would mitigate that. Some instances might even have a feature to delay voting for a very short time to allow for cancellations.
So, would it stay in your public voting history? For any other instances that are set up for archiving and registering the history of the Fediverse, yes. But in almost every other case, no. Most fediverse instances will honor when you have cancelled an upvote or a downvote.
Great explanation, thank you!