Noses are under rated. It’s so easy for us to make devices that can see like eyes using cameras, or hear like ears using microphones, but it’s super difficult to make a device the can smell like a nose. I want something it my house that can smell, and record smell to experience later. Probably not too useful but it would be neat.
nose are overrated af, mine basically not funtioning 60% of the time. Tried some procedural to cure it but to no avails.
Nahh. They are undereyes.
Light and sound are both perceptions of (in some ways) very simple things: different frequencies and intensities of electromagnetic radiation (light) and air compression waves (sound). It’s physics.
Smell and taste are both so many more types of physical molecules coming in contact with sensory organs. It’s chemistry!
By the way if you’re curious, I just went to a talk about the incredible variety of touch/pressure/heat/pain sensors in our skin. It’s worth diving into.
I know we have electronic gas detectors that we call sniffers that can show a bunch of pre programmed airborne chemicals and their quantities
tell me!
The talk was recorded. Enjoy!
<3
Noses are under eyed
I dunno, my nose barely works. Probably not that hard to make a comparable device
I would love to have this. I’d use it to triangulate that intermittent weird smell.
The closest is probably electron spectroscopy.
It’s actually not that dififcult to make a machine that can “smell.” There are devices that detect the chemical makeup of specific scents to detect things like explosives. And I don’t mean dogs.
I would also say smoke detectors “smell” the smoke, since they work basically the same way detecting particles of something in the air that get captured by its sensor.
I agree with your general sentiment, but it’s not easy to make cameras at all, they are truly marvels of engineering. If you look at modern cell phone cameras it’s just straight up magic that would have been inconceivable only 30 years ago. It took decades and so much money to get where we are on cameras these days. If the same effort would have been put into a nose like device, we would have something much more capable than a human nose and even most animal noses. Humans have pretty bad noses compared to some other animals.
Like you say probably not too useful, but for applications where there is a use, we already have amazing devices. For example detectors worn by people in certain jobs that alert whenever a specific gas is detected. These are specifically made to detect a single kind of molecule and are often much better at it than any nose ever could be. And they save lives every day.
Um, Kodak released a digital camera in 1994.
NASA was using digital scanning to replace film on satellites in the early 70’s.
Your point stands though, that digital cameras are a bit like magic. It’s astounding the capability we all carry with us.
Sure but modern cellphone cameras are so far ahead of those early devices, it’s mind boggling. The size, resolution, color range, speed, power usage and all of the crazy processing that’s going on. Being able to do both photos and video. Not to mention complex moving lenses in a tiny package. Stuff like incorporating a mems based accelerometer to apply real time image stabilization is just bonkers. All of this stuff was known in principle, but the advancements are huge. And in principle the sensor is just CMOS, an old technology, but the modern sizes and stacked technology is truly amazing. Those older devices would have been CCD based, with CMOS thought to be unsuitable, but modern technology has made it possible. Not to mention being able to do stuff like compressing and storing 4K 60fps video on the fly without issue. And compress it to such a degree, a regular phone can easily store a lot of video, no switching out media all the time.
Stuff like modern cell phone cameras is, to me, proof we are really living in the future. Sure we didn’t get flying cars or space travel or anything like that. But technology has been advancing at a rapid pace and regular people having access to such a high tech device at any second is pretty cool.
Modern cameras, yes. Film cameras have existed for ages though, and they’re not very complex, yet give good results (given long enough exposure). There’s not even a prototype for smell-cameras due to the reactions involved (see other comment).
No space.
If we were sentient dogs with thumbs, we would have made it happen. If for no other reason than the dog people would need to digitize smells for modern IDs like passports and licenses.







