I don’t have very much experience on cordless tools apart from using DeWalt at home and Makita at work, both at a DIY level capacity. The 18V era is as capable as I will ever need. While trying to expand the range of tools at home though, the influx of house brands (Worksite at my local store) at very low prices became enticing. These items often advertise battery compatibility with big brands and seem sturdy enough. Wonder what everybody is using and how did you make the decision?
I use Ryobi because my dad used Ryobi and because I only do around the house projects mostly. I’m not doing renovation/construction work on the regular.
My brother uses a mix of Milwaukee and Festool, has done lots of light construction at his home and has a wood shop in his garage.
Ultimately the best advice I got was to buy a tool from somewhere like Harbpr Freight. If I use that tool enough to break it/wear it out then invest in a better branded one.
my tool story
I’m 1/2 way between the occasional DIY and a tradesmen. I used to have 150acres and was forever building stuff, I started with Ryobi but it proved useless, eg the drill couldn’t drive a 12mm auger bit through hardwood posts etc so i invested in a Makita kit, was awesome. I used it extensively, added a couple extra cheap home brand tools to fill in the gaps. Then we had a bushfire raze our place and I lost them all, eventually replaced them all with a Bosch Blue set. They have also proved to be excellent, i don’t know if cheaper angle grinders still don’t have a lock on switch but that’s worth the price of entry alone.
We are now on only 4 acres but it’s an older place, some renovations and regular repair and my gfs a keen veg. gardener, so I built a small hot house from recycled materials and a few other things. I use the tools regularly, yesterday the impact driver, today the drill, day before the angle grinder, drop saw and reciprocating saw. Have added to the kit I bought; hedge trimmer, mitre saw, jigsaw, circular saw, reciprocating saw and use all of them, all. Bosch Blue all 18V battery.
Wish i had a really good bandsaw, had a cheap one (a plug in Ryobi) once and it was useless.
I have grown to love the Ryobi of tools, i think they are at a great price point. I think the technology is pretty similar across the big consumer-focused brands, my advice would be to just pick one brand with a lot of selection so a couple of batteries can power a whole home of tools.
Also, for things you plan on using often, like a drill, spend a little extra for a brushless motor. For something you only plan on using very occasionally dont bother and save yourself the cash
I have Makita tools, I like that they aren’t owned by a giant corporation and the quality is alright. They aren’t the cheapest or most powerful but they get the job done.
I have Stihl AP stuff for larger tools like the leaf blower and lawn mower. My dad swears by his Bosch tools, they are high quality but are a bit harder to find
Other than a drill cordless tools make little sense for DIY. Just prepare your work station an do the work there. If you’re not stealing catalytic converters or working on sites with no electricity you really don’t need to carry your tools around and it’s safer to unplug them when not in use.
Definitely disagree with that, a lot of DIY work (like work in an attic, crawl space our outside) is not conducive to setting up a workstation with power. And even it was, cords are a hassle.
And as far as safety goes electrical cables are not only a trip hazard but also, when working with things like angle grinders or saws, an electrocution risk. Unless your buying sketchy shit online the risk of a battery fire is pretty manageable.
I think it also depends if you have a property (garden etc), and there are more useful cordless tools than just a drill.
Eg. a multitool, a reciprocating saw and a cordless angle grinder are really useful due to their flexibility, which cordless enhances.
No one needs a cordless miter saw our drill press for their diy though.You’re right, gardening is an exception here as you can’t bring the things you’re cutting to the work station. Probably some other exceptions exist as well but it’s still good to think if you really need cordless. Collecting them just because they are not that expensive doesn’t make much sense.
I started out with Dewalt after buying my house but have since shifted to Bauer from Harbor Freight for new tool purchases since the batteries are like 1/3 the price. Ive tried some Chinese Dewalt batteries from Amazon and they gave up the ghost after about 6 months of light use. I just cant justify spending $200 on a single brand-name battery so im still rocking all the 2AH “included with the kit” batteries for my Dewalt tools.
My sister also gifted me a Mikwaukee electric ratchet which works great and has great battery life. If I were to start over I’d probably go with Milwaukee instead of Dewalt since they have by far the biggest selection of cordless tools. After that would be Bauer but theyre fairly limited and are mostly automotive related stuff outside of basic drills and impact drivers.
Whatever brand you pick, always shop sales, especially for batteries.
All the major brands have deals like “buy a tool, get a free battery” or “buy 1 battery, get another free” or “buy 1 battery, get a tool free”.
Personally, I like Milwaukee M12 system for home. It’s cheaper than the 18v stuff while still getting Milwaukee quality, plus the chargers work with both, so any tool i need that’s m18 only will use the same charger. Dewalt also has a very capable 12v line of tools.
The full m12 hamner-drill & impact driver kit cost the same as the m18 hammer-drill kit.
For the random home brads do a bit of reasearch. Personally I would avoid “Worksite” due the lack of online presence at major retailer. Their own website lists a whole ton of tools (no prices), but they’re non-existant anywhere else besides a amazon store page that only has few tire inflators and batteries. You can’t price compare to anything. (And I’m pretty confident there is AI in the marketing images, at least the web banner for sure)
The claim that it works with “big-brand” batteires, is very likely bullshit. I didn’t see any indication of that on their website, and the battery on the amazon store says “for worksite tools only”. It does look very similar to dewalt, so maybe it does work and they just don’t talk about it?
Anyway, ignoreing the battery thing, my biggest question is who do you go to if the things stops working? 1 month your local store might take care of it, but what about in 3 months or 3 years? Worksite’s website has no warrenty info and the only contact info is for china. Most of the name brands you can walk into the store you bought it from and they’ll get you squared away. Even Harbor Frieght has a clear, and easy to deal with warranty.
As I’m sure you’ve gathered from all the replies, it doesn’t really matter. Some brands’ designs for one tool might be a little better than average, a different brand might have a different better tool, but in the big picture they’re all pretty comparative.
I fix tools as part of my job and most of the bigger names are about the same inside.
I buy Makita for personal use simply because they are an independent company. Most places I’ve worked use Milwaukee.
One side note, Craftsman is just a brand name, it has never been one company. It’s always been sourced from mid/low tier suppliers.
Makita are unique in that they design using standard parts and they publish schematics freely, which minimises long term cost of ownership if you’re handy
I have a small cordless metabo screwdriver / drill, and that’s it. Everything else is still with cord.
The decision was just because of the better mobility of the small one. I don’t want a cordless “fleet”.
If you really want to go down a rabbit hole, check out the torque test channel on YouTube.
They have expanded into quite a few different tool types, although originally they only tested the torque of impact drivers. (Hence the name)
I think it was around 2008, when 18v was pretty new, I got a dewalt drill and bit driver. The pair were on sale at the hardware store. Used lightly for work and home, and mostly lived in truck. 5 years later I bought more 18v dewalt because they still worked great. That first bit driver is in rough shape now, but still runs. Batteries hang in quite well. Have an adaptor and use dewalt batteries to power a GPS base station.
I bought into ryobi
My reasons were
-
They’re cheap. No, they’re often not the most heavy-duty of tools, but they’ve been more than adequate for my needs as a somewhat advanced DIY homeowner type. If I was really putting my tools through their pages on a job site day in and day out and relying on them to make a living I probably would’ve invested a bit more in them.
-
Piggybacking off of that, I discovered Direct Tools Outlet, where you can get their returns/refurbished/factory-blemished stuff for cheap. They also handle rigid and one or two other brands, and I’m sure most of the other brands have their own similar outlet thing, but I don’t see them talked about as much as DTO.
-
They have a pretty huge selection of tools available, I’m pretty confident that they make every power tool I may ever need, and it’s nice that they all run on the same battery. They make a lot of stuff I don’t see myself ever needing too, but you never know.
-
They’ve really stuck by their battery platform, if you have their old blue NiCad batteries and tools, they still work just fine with the newer bright green lithium stuff. You can still even buy a new charger for the NiCad batteries if you somehow still have some of those kicking around in working order. Some other brand have changed up their batteries once or twice over the years, so you’re kind of fucked if your older tools or batteries shit the bed and you kind of need to start over with brand new stuff. And I don’t really see that changing anytime soon because it feels like they’ve made the battery a pretty big part of their brand identity. They’ve added a couple other parallel lines like the 40v outdoor stuff and their little USB rechargeable tools (and I do have a couple of the USB tools as well, and I think they’re great) but I’m not seeing any signs that they’re going to drastically change or drop their main tool/battery line anytime soon.
-
I like the bright green. Nothing else in the sorts of places I’m working is that color, so if I set my drill down in a pile of junk I can always spot it right away.
They’ve added a couple other parallel lines like the 40v outdoor stuff
I’ve been happy with the 40v stuff. They also have a 300W inverter that takes those batteries, and they’ve got a few power stations that use 4 6Ah batteries to give 1800W. I haven’t seen any reviews of the power stations (versus all the product reviews of something like a jackery), but having removable, multi-function cells is a pretty neat idea that I hope has legs.
Yeah I love the 300W inverter, I use it to power my gas tank less water heater in outages.
-
If it’s for home use, any of the Name Brands are good.
Also,If it’s for home use,do you even need a battery? They are bulky, they wear out,
charger goes missing, the power connections go obsolete, they arent charged up on the day you need to use them.
Also,wired is safer if you have other people,kids or pets around,as you can just plug them out if you are looking at something else and need to let the tool sit for a while.

Ryobi is without a doubt Hufflepuff
Missing the 5th house, Ridgid.
Lifetime warranty crew!!
And Black&Decker
Maybe i made a mistake but I ended up with Kobalt.
If I had not gotten into rigid when I worked at Home Depot I likely would have gone with kobalt.
deleted by creator





